Rules of Murder by Julianna Deering

(This post does contain affiliate links; read the disclosure page for details.)

Author: Julianna Deering
Publisher: Bethany House
Publication Date: 2013
Find the Book Elsewhere: 
Amazon | Goodreads
Find the review elsewhere:  
Series: A Drew Farthering Mystery – book 1
Genre: Fiction; Historical, Mystery
Rating: ★★★★★

Life for Andrew Farthering has been an easy one. As the only son of a wealthy entrepreneur, Drew lived a comfortable country life but since the passing of his father, he was left with his widowed mother – a woman who never emotionally connected with her son, as a child, Drew became enamored with mystery novels, which instilled in him a love of solving a jolly good puzzle. His stepfather, who was a business partner with his father wishes Drew would join him in the business, however Drew has never felt totally at ease with the man. Coinciding in the aftermath of his mother scandalizing the Farthering name, trouble comes a-calling in Drew’s village – or rather right on his own estate grounds, Drew has more mystery than he could have ever wished for. With the help of his best friend, Nick and a sassy American guest, Madeline Parker, Drew and the gang search for the clues that are eluding the police only to find out murder is not just the stuff Agatha Christie novels are made of.  

Some books are decent at passing time, others make it onto reader’s inevitable “best of” lists and then there are those that additionally earn the honor of a spot on avid reader’s keeper shelves (and we all know how limiting this space can be! *wink*) along with flummoxing reviewers. Rules of Murder has the distinction of the latter. Julianna Deering’s first in a trilogy series was such a charming, interesting novel that I feel quite at a loss as to how best to convey that. Co-mingling elements of classic British mysteries (think in the tradition of Agatha Christie's Marple) with sophisticated features inspired by the likes of Downton Abbey, ‘Rules’ has a snazzy narrative that isn’t one I’ll be soon to forget. One of its best assets is its strong male presence thanks to Drew. Not many books have a prominent male “voice” and in Drew, readers are rewarded with a good ‘un. He’s prominently male (and those of you who long for a male characters to be just that will totally understand what I mean) yet there is a cheeky, flirty side to him that still manages to be gentlemanly and irresistible, add in the fact that he’s through and through British, and what you are left with is golden. There is a price to pay for the strong perspective of Drew, that being the absence of his lady love, Madeline. Many readers will find fault with her rare appearances and the underdeveloped romantics. I did not – this is for two reasons.

Unlike most series, Drew and Madeline are going to be primary for three books – this is self-explanatory in the series name, which gives Deering more freedom to keep the romance in play without “showing” too much, too early. What she begins with these two leaves us wanting more, and that is excellent writing. I adored these two quintessential love birds together; from his rebuffed marriage proposals and professions of love to Madeline’s cute quips and steadfast loyalty, there couldn’t have been a better duo in this setting. The second reason I was unaffected by the whirlwind relationship was the era. Everything these two did or said to each other constantly brought to life the pictures any reader has of this era – from the dialogue to the “brash” reactions, everything fit neatly into its box, and I say this with only the highest regard, which leads straight into the authentic research Deering seems to have woven into her novel. None of the prose seemed out of place or awkward leaving a reader nothing if not impressed by the time the final page is turned – that and eager to read Death by the Book!

Before wrapping this up, I cannot exclude the excellent mystery qualities. The surprise isn’t so much who the man behind the mayhem is, as the body count. Great Gatsby! That was something quite unexpected as the number of deaths tallies up to five if memory is serving me correctly, instead of keeping the perpetrator in the shadows (or at least in the latter parts of the book when one can make an educated guess), what he gets away with is the real surprise. Fortunately, Julianna does everything for a purpose, making nothing about this book “useless” in any form. And if there is one thing that is a sure thing here, it’s a sparkling good time – from secondary characters (like Nick whom I also loved) to the mentions of motor cars, there’s never tedious moment. Like a fellow reviewer boasted, anyone who enjoyed ‘Rules’ is going to be beyond eager for more adventures from Drew & Company; if its impending sequel is anything like this novel, count me in!

Synopsis: Drew Farthering loves a good mystery, although he generally expects to find it in the pages of a novel, not on the grounds of his country estate. When a weekend party at Farthering Place is ruined by murder and the police seem flummoxed, Drew decides to look into the crime himself. With the help of his best friend, Nick Dennison, an avid mystery reader, and Madeline Parker, a beautiful and whip-smart American debutante staying as a guest, the three try to solve the mystery as a lark, using the methods from their favorite novels.

Soon, financial irregularities at Drew’s stepfather’s company come to light and it’s clear that all who remain at Farthering Place could be in danger. Trying hard to remain one step ahead of the killer–and trying harder to impress Madeline–Drew must decide how far to take this game. - Goodreads

Coming Next from Julianna Deering: Drew Farthering wants nothing more than to finish out the summer of 1932 with the announcement of his engagement to Madeline Parker. Instead, he finds himself in the middle of another murder case. The family lawyer has been killed, a cryptic message stuck to the body with an antique hatpin. Drew is content to leave solving this one to the police, but when the dead man's widow asks for his assistance, he can't help but be pulled in.

Life at home is just as troubling. Madeline still hasn't decided whether she will accept his proposal of marriage, and worse, her formidable maiden aunt, Ruth Jansen, appears at Farthering Place with the sole objective of convincing Madeline to return to America.

When a second murder occurs, and another baffling message secured with a hatpin is found at the scene, the village of Farthering St. John is thrown into a tizzy. And it seems Drew and Madeline and their friend, Nick Dennison, are the ones who will have to crack the case before the Hatpin Murderer strikes again. – via Goodreads, February 2014

Sincere thanks to the publisher for providing a complimentary copy of this book for reviewing purposes.


  1. Replies
    1. Me, too, Ruth! Loved that it was so "different" from usual Christian fiction. :)

  2. Great review!!! I'm working on mine, but my thoughts exactly! I can't wait for the next one :)

    1. Neither can I, Jamie! Yippee - now you'll have me on the lookout for your review, girl. Excited. :)

  3. When I saw the cover I was like hmmm, not too interested--but your review combined elements of things I love--the 30s! Agatha Christie! Britain!--so I'm definitely going to give this story a try!

    1. The cover *is* uniquely odd but I liked it - something quite different from the usual. Glad you think 'Rules' sounds like it may be worth a read, Rebeka. I LOVED it. Plus, oh, my, yes! There are a lot of similarities to Marple and of course, Drew is British. ;-)

      Happy reading!

  4. Replies
    1. Absolutely! It's worth that, Juju. Hope you like the book. :)

  5. Almost half-way through with this one. I love the dialog! Makes me want to rewatch The Great Gatsby with Leo DiCaprio, at least it'll be out soon... lol

    1. Me, too, Rosie - I adore the whip-smart dialogue and the "fun" in every scene. CANNOT wait for your review, girl. :)

      Ooo! Did you like The Great Gatsby? I'll rent it for its pretty costumes and the cast, but that's about all I plan on liking. ;-)

    2. I just finished it! Ohmyword, yes! If nothing else, the dialog is the best part of the whole book. :)

      I did! They followed the book very well, as I recall. Aside from one scene, I felt the movie was well done and MUCH better than it's predecessors. There's so much more to the movie than the pretty costumes. :p lol I hope you like it!

    3. Yay! Happy you enjoyed it until the end. Bring on book two! Going to be by later to read your review. :)

      Knowing that there is more to 'Gatsby' and that it follows the book is nice to hear. I am such a... hmm... what to call it!? A girl who finds miserable endings distasteful so that is why I am digging my feet in and dreading the movie - well, expect for these costumes. ;) LOL.

      Thanks for sharing - I hope I'll like it, too. :)

  6. I JUST got on blogger to post my review of this book! And you're right- the real surprise was *how many* murders there were! I can't wait for the next books in this series! I quite like the cover, too- it just really showcases the whole feel of the book.

    1. Alright - so cool, Hayden! Because of all those murders, this put me in mind of the ITV series Marple and it was a fun bit of puzzle to unscramble. I was completely won over by Drew and Madeline and for sure, cannot wait for the sequel. Should be a good 'un. :)

      Off to read your review!

  7. Yay! I finished my copy yesterday and it's definitely a favorite! I wouldn't have thought Deering could pull it off - I mean, a 1930's British Christian Murder Mystery?? But wow, she really nailed it on all counts. The murder had a few small clichés and the Christian theme was a little abrupt, but other than that, it's a keeper! I'm glad to have read your intro for the next book; hadn't seen that yet!

    1. Hooray! So pleased you enjoyed the book, Kellie. I must admit seeing your status on Goodreads for this one made me curious to know if you were liking the book. Some of the Christianity wasn't fleshed out like it should have been (I agree), however I am hoping that since the three-book series is going to be about Drew and Madeline that Deering will further develop this.

      Doesn't book two sound terrific!? Cannot wait to get my hands on that one - and 'Rules' is certainly going on my "best of" list! :)

      Cannot wait to read your review. :)

  8. I'm glad you liked this one! I'm so excited about it, I'm thinking about buying it! *gasp* ;)

    1. Thanks, Tammy - this was a charming read! Do you like Sherlock Holmes or Agatha Christie's Marple? There were reflections of those in this novel and the result was the start of an excellent series! :)

      Hope you enjoy 'Rules'!

      Now that I review so many Christian novels, my buying nowadays is more about YA/secular fiction. It's been fun to discover some new authors. ;-)

  9. {This is my other comment to enter the Blackmoore book giveaway. :)}
    Rules of Murder sounds interesting. Sherlock Holmes was my main book to read during middle and early high school. :) Agatha Christie meets Downton Abbey? Sweet! :)

    1. My thoughts exactly, Kerry - when I saw that Agatha Christie, 'Downton' tagline, I *knew* this book would be a keeper. :)

      Hope you enjoy it.


Have a thought? Don't be shy, go ahead and leave one... or two... or three! I reply to every comment. If you're new to the blog, please don't hesitate to introduce yourself and your blog - we love chatting around here!

Feedback and every comment is appreciated and read - I always leave a response; your opinions are respected and I ask that you show mine the same courtesy.

(If you post under “anonymous,” please leave a name. If you don't have a Google account, you can type your name into the Name/URL and if you have no site, just leave "URL" blank.)

If you are still reading my ramblings, thank you for following this little blog and for being one of its supporters. I’ve enjoyed getting to know each of you, friends!

[name=Rissi] [img=Your Image Url Here] [description=auburn-hair. #bookblogger. downton abbey. inspys. internet-photo-shy. silver petticoat contributor. writer. the aspiration is to someday write professionally. a girl can dream, right?] (facebook= (twitter= (instagram= (bloglovin= (pinterest=Pinterest Profile Url) (tumblr=Tumblr Profile Url)