This Is Us, Pilot (2016) – Emotional Drama Connecting Three Stories (Plus THAT Twist)

Thursday, September 29, 2016

I’m not much for the “emotional” drama. But once in a while I sit down, hit play and walk in with an open mind. Such was the case with NBC’s latest show.

Life is bliss for Rebecca and Jack (Mandy Moore, Milo Vintimiglia). They’re a mere weeks away from welcoming their triplets, and are settling into a new house in anticipation of their arrival. But everything changes when Rebecca goes into labor early. 

Life is at a standstill, ending with a question mark for Randall (Sterling K. Brown). As a baby, he was left at a fire station. All he knows is his mother died and his father, who he has just found through a PI, abandoned him. Even with a successful career and now, his own family, something is missing.

Siblings Kate (Chrissy Metz) and Kevin (Justin Hartley) are far from living their perfect lives. Kate is an overweight single woman struggling with turning 36 and being so far from where she envisioned her life. Kevin is a B-actor no longer satisfied with being the “sexy” star of his B-show “The Manny.” As a result he has a meltdown on the set. 

One day connects these people, and one choice leads to a future none of them imagined.

As the trailers played for this show I was intrigued but not enough to rush into seeing it. The day after it aired, I downloaded the first episode and put some space between its airing and finally watching it. When I finally did, I came away surprised by how well composed the scripting and story was. Tightly compacted into its first hour is the setup of something I can see – surprisingly – working really well as a series. Though judging only by its pilot, I don’t see it being this good long term.

Touted as a kind of replacement for Parenthood (NBC), that was one show I never watched. Surmising from what I have gathered of the show and what I know of This Is Us, I can see that comparison being legit. The various threads that tie these characters together are interesting. Each one is compelling. What I liked so well about the pilot was its pursuit of genuine emotion over heedless, thoughtless and tiring drama. Sure, as the show furthers, there are bound to be some challenges or drama that doesn’t fit, but for the most part… everything comes across as emotionally fulfilling.

The performances in particular help sell this. I quickly became swept up in Rebecca and Jack’s love story (even though it’s established); unique markers configure the relationship between the siblings; and finally Randall’s story is wrought with heart wrenching revelations and promises to be thoroughly rewarding. Everyone had a story to tell, and somehow the pilot felt very complete. As the credits rolled, there was a sense of completeness to everything that I never expected.

If you’re looking for something outside of the over-the-top comedies or the frequent crime dramas, This is Us might be your cup of tea. If however, you want something more linear, then this drama is not your ideal. It will suit, as is true of everything, a specific audience. As nearly every show does, I’ve little doubt the pursuant episode will differ from the pilot, which means I’m leery about continuing on. Do I leave off where I feel happy with what I saw and imagine what I’d like of these characters futures? Or do I continue on and risk disenchantment? 

This is the question I am now left pondering.

(Content: There is a backside shot of female and male nudity. A married couple flirt (he’s naked) and there are various sexual innuendoes. The show is rated TV14.)

Photos: NBC


  1. I'm already behind on this show because my sister hasn't been home long enough to watch it with me. She made me swear not to watch it without her. *grumbles*
    And um--its Milo/Jess from Gilmore Girls. I'll watch the show till it gets cancelled. LOLOL That's all I know right off and I haven't even watched it yet.

    1. Oh noes! Bummer for those promises, right!? :)

      Hope your sis has been home long enough at this point for you two to catch up. What'd you think? I've not watched another episode, but I'd love to know what you think!

      You're Team Jess then!? ;) I have to finish the series and as such am still undecided. Although Dean is pretty much OFF my cool list.

  2. So I watched this and I really agree with you on a lot of this. It almost felt like it could have been a movie, it felt so complete. I worry about future episodes too, especially after the "big" end- how can subsequent episodes compete? That said, I DID really like it- I was crying like a baby at several parts! I will definitely watch the next episode, and I hope that it CAN continue... but like you said, I am a bit concerned that it won't really have the steam. Fabulous review!

    1. Hi, Shannon! Thanks so much for visiting. Always glad to read what you think.

      I'm glad you enjoyed this. I will probably check out subsequent episodes, but yeah, it felt so "full" and as if the ending was appropriate and well rounded. Still, I have hopes it'll have the stamina to continue on, and I saw on Twitter the next episode had another twist? So maybe the writer's will surprise!

      THANK YOU for reading. :)

  3. That ending really surprised me, too. But I did watch the second episode and I liked it so I'll continue with this series. The ending of the second episode had be yelling at the tv, though. I was like, "No freaking way!" :)

    1. That's what I hear too, Dawn! (Episode two has another "twist.") I've not watched any more episodes, but I probably will. For now, I feel satisfied with the story this pilot told. :)

  4. I felt a lot like you did, I was in no rush to watch it but it certainly looked cute and feel-good. But wow, did this pilot surprise me with how well it was made! My sisters and mom are actually obsessed with this show. I didn't want to watch the second for fear of it not living up to the pilot, but when I did I thought it was as good as the first. Fingers crossed they keep it up!

    1. Good to know, Bekah! I'm not sure I'll keep up with it (for now) for reasons. Some of them being the following:

      + Blindspot (yeah, I'm still on S1 of that one!)
      + Scorpion (season two)
      + Stitchers (season one)
      + Chuck (season three)

      ... and probably countless others to say nothing of the 2016 pilots I'm working my way through. All that rambling aside, I AM pleased to know it's holding its own thus far. That's encouraging.

      Three cheers for TV finds that wind up surprising. :)


Have a thought? Don't be shy, go ahead and leave one... or two... or three! I reply to every comment. If you're new to the blog, please don't hesitate to introduce yourself and your blog - we love chatting around here!

Feedback and every comment is appreciated and read - I always leave a response; your opinions are respected and I ask that you show mine the same courtesy.

(If you post under “anonymous,” please leave a name. If you don't have a Google account, you can type your name into the Name/URL and if you have no site, just leave "URL" blank.)

If you are still reading my ramblings, thank you for following this little blog and for being one of its supporters. I’ve enjoyed getting to know each of you, friends!

Latest Instagrams

© Finding Wonderland. Design by FCD.